People: William F. Dugan, Partner

William F. Dugan

Partner

Chicago
Direct: (312) 460-5933
Fax: (312) 460-7933
0

William F. Dugan is a partner of Seyfarth Shaw LLP, the leading national labor and employment law firm.  Mr. Dugan is a member of the Labor & Employment Practice Group and resides in the firm’s Chicago office.

Mr. Dugan has represented employers in a wide array of state and federal matters, including litigation of employment contract claims, wrongful discharge claims, privacy claims, various tort based common law claims, harassment claims, and discrimination and retaliation claims brought pursuant to Title VII, the FMLA, the ADA, the ADEA and various other state and local statutes.  Mr. Dugan practices extensively before a variety of local, state and federal agencies, tribunals and courts, including practice before the National Labor Relations Board, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, several federal appellate courts and the United States Supreme Court.

Mr. Dugan has extensive experience in the employment and labor litigation arenas throughout the United States.  Among his various cases, Mr. Dugan was co-lead counsel in a recent federal court multi-plaintiff race discrimination and harassment lawsuit litigated for nine weeks to verdict before a Detroit, Michigan jury, lead counsel in a recent multi-plaintiff sex harassment and retaliation lawsuit litigated to verdict before a Chicago, Illinois jury, and lead counsel in a recent single-plaintiff breach of contract lawsuit litigated to verdict before an Ann Arbor, Michigan jury.  Similarly, Mr. Dugan was trial counsel for a twelve employee discharge case in Freeport, Texas, as well as trial counsel in an unfair labor practice hearing wherein nearly one hundred unfair labor practice charges were litigated to verdict over forty-eight hearing days in Syracuse, New York.  Mr. Dugan was also trial counsel in the first sexual orientation discrimination lawsuit held in Urbana, Illinois.  Currently, Mr. Dugan is defense counsel in one of the largest pay and promotion gender discrimination class/collective actions in the nation.

Mr. Dugan has also achieved favorable results prior to trial.  For instance, Mr. Dugan recently defeated class certification and prevailed at summary judgment on the named plaintiffs’ claims leading to a quick case resolution.  Moreover, Mr. Dugan has filed counter-claims when appropriate, achieving various judgments against vexatious plaintiffs.  When prudent, Mr. Dugan has also been able to resolve cases favorably prior to trial as evidenced by a recent nine plaintiff matter resolved on very favorable terms in Circuit Court, St. Clair County, Illinois, recognized by the American Tort Reform Association as one of the five “Judicial Hellholes” in the nation.

In the union arena, Mr. Dugan routinely provides legal advice to management in election campaigns, represents management in labor arbitrations and unfair labor practice and representation hearings before the National Labor Relations Board.  As part of Seyfarth Shaw LLP’s Business Restructuring and Transactional Employment Group, Mr. Dugan devotes a portion of his practice to advising clients concerning labor and employment issues in mergers, sales, joint ventures, workforce reductions and other business restructuring matters.

William F. Dugan is a partner of Seyfarth Shaw LLP, the leading national labor and employment law firm.  Mr. Dugan is a member of the Labor & Employment Practice Group and resides in the firm’s Chicago office.

Mr. Dugan has represented employers in a wide array of state and federal matters, including litigation of employment contract claims, wrongful discharge claims, privacy claims, various tort based common law claims, harassment claims, and discrimination and retaliation claims brought pursuant to Title VII, the FMLA, the ADA, the ADEA and various other state and local statutes.  Mr. Dugan practices extensively before a variety of local, state and federal agencies, tribunals and courts, including practice before the National Labor Relations Board, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, several federal appellate courts and the United States Supreme Court.

Mr. Dugan has extensive experience in the employment and labor litigation arenas throughout the United States.  Among his various cases, Mr. Dugan was co-lead counsel in a recent federal court multi-plaintiff race discrimination and harassment lawsuit litigated for nine weeks to verdict before a Detroit, Michigan jury, lead counsel in a recent multi-plaintiff sex harassment and retaliation lawsuit litigated to verdict before a Chicago, Illinois jury, and lead counsel in a recent single-plaintiff breach of contract lawsuit litigated to verdict before an Ann Arbor, Michigan jury.  Similarly, Mr. Dugan was trial counsel for a twelve employee discharge case in Freeport, Texas, as well as trial counsel in an unfair labor practice hearing wherein nearly one hundred unfair labor practice charges were litigated to verdict over forty-eight hearing days in Syracuse, New York.  Mr. Dugan was also trial counsel in the first sexual orientation discrimination lawsuit held in Urbana, Illinois.  Currently, Mr. Dugan is defense counsel in one of the largest pay and promotion gender discrimination class/collective actions in the nation.

Mr. Dugan has also achieved favorable results prior to trial.  For instance, Mr. Dugan recently defeated class certification and prevailed at summary judgment on the named plaintiffs’ claims leading to a quick case resolution.  Moreover, Mr. Dugan has filed counter-claims when appropriate, achieving various judgments against vexatious plaintiffs.  When prudent, Mr. Dugan has also been able to resolve cases favorably prior to trial as evidenced by a recent nine plaintiff matter resolved on very favorable terms in Circuit Court, St. Clair County, Illinois, recognized by the American Tort Reform Association as one of the five “Judicial Hellholes” in the nation.

In the union arena, Mr. Dugan routinely provides legal advice to management in election campaigns, represents management in labor arbitrations and unfair labor practice and representation hearings before the National Labor Relations Board.  As part of Seyfarth Shaw LLP’s Business Restructuring and Transactional Employment Group, Mr. Dugan devotes a portion of his practice to advising clients concerning labor and employment issues in mergers, sales, joint ventures, workforce reductions and other business restructuring matters.

Education

  • J.D., University of Notre Dame Law School (1995)
    cum laude
  • B.A., University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (1992)

Admissions

  • Illinois

Courts

  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth, Seventh, Eighth, Tenth, and the District of Columbia Circuits
  • Illinois Court of Appeals
  • U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (Trial Bar)
  • Several Other United States District Courts

Affiliations

  • American Bar Association
  • Society For Human Resource Management
  • Wheaton Housing Commission

Representative Engagements

Representative Published Decisions

  • Betts v. Costco Wholesale, Corporation, (Award of $1 in attorney’s fees in multi-plaintiff action post-trial)
  • Books, Jr. v. City of Normal, et al., (summary judgment granted in disability discrimination suit)
  • Byker v. Sequent Computer Systems, Inc., (summary judgment granted on breach of contract, quantum merit, Illinois Wage Payment & Collection Act, Illinois Sales Representative Act, retaliatory discharge, and tortious interference with contract suit)
  • EEOC v. Sterling Jewelers Inc., (denial of EEOC’s motion to include punitive damages in stage 1 of litigation)
  • Fons v. American Commercial Lines, Inc., (motion to transfer venue granted)
  • Giddens v. Steak and Ale of Illinois, Inc., et al., (summary judgment granted in favor of corporate and individual defendants on various state and federal claims)
  • Gittings v. Tredegar Corporation, et al,. (summary judgment granted in ADA, ADEA, ERTSA and retaliation suit)
  • Greviskes v. Universities Research Association, Inc., (affirmed district court award to employer of $54,613.50 in fees as sanction for plaintiff's unscrupulous conduct and $14,435.95 in taxable costs; affirmed dismissal of case; court ordered employee to show cause why appellate attorneys fees and costs should not be imposed)
  • Greviskes v. Universities Research Association, Inc., (motion to dismiss granted and attorneys' fees awarded as sanction for plaintiff's unscrupulous conduct)
  • Hawkins, et al. v. Groot Industries, Inc., et al., (denial of plaintiffs’ motion for class certification)
  • Hawkins, et al. v. Groot Industries, Inc., et al., (summary judgment granted against two named plaintiffs in class action alleging multiple discrimination claims, and harassment and retaliation)
  • Hawkins, et al. v. Groot Industries, Inc., et al., (denial of reassignment of later filed class action with earlier filed class action)
  • In re:  Greyhound Exposition Services, Inc., (no breach of contract where employer did not provide carpenter with certain work opportunities)
  • Jaglieski v. Hilton Chicago, (summary judgment granted in case alleging multiple bases of discrimination)
  • Jock, et. al. v. Sterling Jewelers, Inc. (court vacated arbitration award permitting private Title VIII and EDA class/collective action of with over 20,000 putative class members)
  • Kneibert v. Thompson Newspapers, Michigan, Inc., (summary judgment affirmed in age discrimination and retaliation suit)
  • Kotwica v. Rose Packing, Inc., (summary judgment granted in disability discrimination suit)
  • Lindsey v. Concord Buying Group d/b/a A.J. Wright, (denial of plaintiff’s motion for appointment of counsel)
  • Lindsey v. Concord Buying Group d/b/a A.J. Wright, (summary judgment granted in race discrimination suit)
  • McGowan v. Palmer House Hilton, (summary judgment granted in sexual harassment case)
  • Myart v. Doubletree Hotels, Corp., (summary judgment granted in retaliation case and also upholding effectiveness of sexual harassment investigation)
  • Nelson v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, (motion to dismiss granted as to breach of contract and promissory estoppel claims; motion to strike granted as to jury demand and demand for compensatory damages concerning ERISA claims)
  • Nelson v Wachovia Securities, LLC, (summary judgment granted in ERISA/FMLA/breach of contract/age/disability lawsuit)
  • Thompson, et al. v. GES Exposition Services, Inc., (summary judgment granted in six plaintiff discrimination, harassment and retaliation suit)
  • Weber v. Universities Research Association, (summary judgment granted in sex discrimination and retaliation suit).
  • Weber v. Universities Research Association, (affirmed district court grant of summary judgment)
  • Wilson v. Palmer House Hilton, (summary judgment granted in racial harassment, discrimination, constructive discharge and retaliation suit)
  • Zhivanovich v. Unisys Corporation, (summary judgment granted in multiple count discrimination and retaliation case)

Recent/Representative Defense of Multi-Plaintiff/Class Action Cases

  • Betts, et al. v. Costco Wholesale Corporation, (co-lead defense counsel in multi-plaintiff race discrimination and harassment lawsuit tried to verdict over nine weeks)
  • Butler et al. v. American Cable & Telephone, Inc.,(lead defense counsel in FLSA collective action)
  • Butler, et al. v. American Cable & Telephone, LLC, (lead defense counsel in FLSA, IWPCA and multiple separate class and collective claims)
  • Cobbs, et al. v. Mid City Salon Resources, LLC, (lead defense counsel in multi-plaintiff sex harassment and retaliation lawsuit tried to verdict)
  • Curry, et al. v. Chateau Del Mar, et al., (defense counsel in multi-plaintiff sex harassment/retaliation/intentional infliction of emotional distress/assault and battery lawsuit)
  • DeCarlo, et al. v. The TJX Companies, Inc., et al., (lead defense counsel in multi-plaintiff sex and race discrimination/ wrongful discharge/intentional infliction of emotional distress/respondeat superior/defamation lawsuit)
  • Duke, et al. v. Staples The Office Superstore, LLC, et al., (lead defense counsel multi-plaintiff assault/battery/negligent hiring/negligent retention lawsuit)
  • EEOC v. Area Temps, Inc., (defense counsel in pattern and practice race/national origin/sex/age discrimination and retaliation lawsuit)
  • EEOC v. Chateau Del Mar, Inc.,(defense counsel in multi-plaintiff retaliation lawsuit)
  • EEOC v. Chateau Del Mar, Inc., Hickory Hills Country Club, Inc., (defense counsel in pattern and practice sex/race discrimination, harassment and retaliation lawsuit)
  • EEOC v. Local 120 United Association of Journeyman and Apprentices of the Plumbing and Pipe Fitting Industry, (defense counsel representing employer in pattern and practice race discrimination lawsuit) 
  • EEOC v. McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood Restaurants, Inc., et al., (defense counsel in pattern and practice race discrimination lawsuit)
  • EEOC v. Outback Steakhouse of Florida, Inc., et al., (defense counsel in pattern and practice sex discrimination lawsuit)
  • EEOC v. Sterling Jewelers Inc., (defense counsel in nationwide pattern and practice sex discrimination lawsuit)
  • Hawkins, et al. v. Groot Industries, Inc., et al., (defense counsel in race/harassment/retaliation class action)
  • Jock, et al. v. Sterling Jewelers Inc., (defense counsel in Title VII and EPA class and collective action with over 20,000 putative class members for alleged gender discrimination in pay and promotions)
  • EEOC v. Federal Cleaning Contractors, Inc., (lead defense counsel in pattern and practice sex discrimination and harassment lawsuit)
  • Landis Plastics, Inc. and United Steel Workers of America AFL-CIO, CLC, (trial counsel in hearing involving approximately one-hundred unfair labor practice charges over forty-eight trial days)
  • Molina, et al. v. Roskam Baking Company and Forge Industrial Staffing, (lead defense counsel in Fair Credit Reporting Act class action)
  • Robles, et al. v. Costco Wholesale Corporation, (defense counsel in nationwide Title III class action)
  • Ross, et al. v. Cox Auto Trader, Inc., et al., (lead defense counsel in nationwide Fair Credit Reporting Act class action)
  • Rios, et al. v. Groot Industries, Inc., et al., (defense counsel in race/national origin/harassment/retaliation class action)
  • Ruess, et al. v. Quill Corporation, et al., (lead defense counsel in multi-plaintiff  recklessand intentional infliction of emotional distress/defamation/appropriation of likeness/negligent supervision lawsuit)
  • The Dow Chemical Company and International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 564, (trial counsel in multi-grievant discharge hearing)
  • Trantham v. American Cable & Telephone, Inc., (lead defense counsel in FLSA collective action)
  • White, et al. v. Abbott Ambulance of Illinois, Inc., (lead defense counsel in multi-plaintiff Minimum Wage Act/retaliatory discharge lawsuit)
  • Wilson, et al. v. GAF Building Materials Corporation, (defense counsel in multi-plaintiff race discrimination/retaliation lawsuit)
  • Williams-Lancaster, et al. v. Pods Enterprises, Inc., (lead defense counsel in multi-plaintiff race/sex/national origin/color discrimination and retaliation/equal pay lawsuit

Recent/Representative Defense of Single-Plaintiff Federal Cases

  • Adams v. Forge Industrial Staffing, (lead defense counsel in age/sex/retaliation lawsuit)
  • Croom v. TJX Companies, Inc., (lead defense counsel in religious discrimination lawsuit)
  • Dryer v. Hudson Technologies, Inc., (lead defense counsel in age/disability lawsuit)
  • Dyxin v. Universities Research Assoc., Inc., d/b/a Ferminational Accelerator Laboratory, (lead defense counsel in FMLA/disability/sex/age/retaliation lawsuit)
  • EEOC v. Kelly Services, Inc., (lead defense counsel in failure to accommodate religious discrimination lawsuit)
  • Hays v. The TJX Companies, Inc., (lead defense counsel in ERISA/disability lawsuit)
  • Hill v. Staples, Inc., (lead defense counsel in race discrimination lawsuit)
  • Hilmer v. The TJX Companies, Inc., et al., (lead defense counsel in FMLA/Title VII retaliation lawsuit)
  • Ingram v. Staples, Inc., (lead defense counsel in race/sex/retaliation lawsuit)
  • Klinker v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, (lead defense counsel in lawsuit involving multiple violations of the ADA and retaliation)
  • Levock v. Costco Wholesale Corporation, (lead defense counsel in breach of contract lawsuit tried to verdict)
  • Mackey v. Staples, Inc., et al., (lead defense counsel in multi-count lawsuit)
  • Mellott v. Universities Research Association, Inc., (lead defense counsel in age/breach of contract/retaliatory discharge lawsuit)
  • Osazuwa v. The TJX Companies d/b/a T.J. Maxx, (lead defense counsel in race/color/national origin/harassment/retaliation lawsuit)
  • Radman v. Staples Office Supercenter East, (lead defense counsel in national origin discrimination lawsuit)
  • Rios v. Costco Wholesale Corporation, (lead defense counsel in sex/age discrimination lawsuit)
  • Vann v. T.J. Maxx, (lead defense counsel in race/age discrimination lawsuit)
  • Weber v. Universities Research Association, Inc., (lead defense counsel in sex discrimination/retaliation lawsuit)

Recent/Representative Defense of Single-Plaintiff State Cases

  • Dollear v. G.F. Connelly Mechanical Contractors, Inc., et al., (lead defense counsel in breach of contract/Illinois Wage Payment and Collection Act lawsuit)
  • Haynes v. Universities Research Association, Inc., (lead defense counsel in breach of contract lawsuit)
  • Lewis v. Marshall’s Inc., (lead defense counsel in race discrimination lawsuit)
  • Loessburg v. Staples The Office Supercenter East, Inc., et al., (lead defense counsel in wrongful discharge lawsuit)
  • McDaniel v. ISP Chemical, Inc., (defense counsel in wrongful discharge/breach of contract/breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing lawsuit)
  • Pedersen v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, et al., (lead defense counsel in negligence/innocent misrepresentation/fraud/false representations/failure to disclose facts (silent fraud)/bad faith promise/promissory estoppel/breach of contract/tortious interference with contract or expectancy lawsuit)
  • Villers v. Costco Wholesale Corporation, (lead defense counsel in breach of contract/disability lawsuit)

Recent/Representative Defense of Arbitration and Administrative Claims

  • Carmeuse PA, Inc. and Laborers’ International, Local 471, (lead trial counsel in representation hearing)
  • Clark v. Vanguard Rental USA, Inc. d/b/a National Car Rental, (lead trial counsel in hearing before the Illinois Human Rights Commission)
  • Ingels v. DWS Scudder Distributors, Inc., Deutsche Bank AG, et al., (lead defense counsel in defamation/bad faith claim tried to verdict)
  • Kross v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, (lead defense counsel in breach of contract/denial of benefits and stock/wrongful termination claim)
  • Local 1, Unite Here and Hilton & Towers Hotel (Fadl Yasin), (lead trial counsel in discharge hearing)
  • Local 1, Unite Here and The Palmer House Hilton (Mohammad Safavi), (lead trial counsel in discharge hearing)
  • Local 1, Unite Here and The Palmer House Hilton (Tiffany Cochran), (lead trial counsel in discharge hearing)
  • Local 1, Unite Here and The Palmer House Hilton (Laticia Woodcox), (lead trial counsel in discharge hearing)
  • Marmaxx Group and Unite Here, (lead trial counsel in contract interpretation hearing)
  • Pedersen v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, et al., (lead defense counsel in negligence/innocent misrepresentation/fraud/false representations/failure to disclose facts (silent fraud)/bad faith promise/promissory estoppel/breach of contract/tortious interference with contract or expectancy claim)
  • Schrimpf v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, (lead defense counsel in age/denial of benefits claim)
  • Sprout v. Carle Foundation Hospital, (trial counsel in first sexual orientation lawsuit brought under ordinance)
  • Struber v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, (lead defense counsel in denial of benefits/fraud/wrongful termination claim)
  • Tierney v. Wachovia Securities, LLC, (lead defense counsel in negligent misrepresentation/fraud/breach of contract claim)

 

Publications